Written by Rorisang Phahlane

This article explains the rights and processes available to Road Accident Fund (RAF) claimants whose injuries have been assessed and determined as “not serious” by the RAF, or where the RAF has failed to decide timeously on whether the claimant’s injuries are serious or not serious. This matters because a claimant can claim general damages only if their injuries are classified as serious.

The process to get a determination on the seriousness of a claimant’s injuries is technical and strictly time bound.

 

Understanding Your Rights After an RAF4 Rejection

General damages are recoverable from the Road Accident Fund (RAF) only where the injury is “serious” – this requirement comes from section 17(1A) of the Road Accident Fund Act 56 of 1996 and Regulation 3 of the Road Accident Fund Regulations, 2008.

A “non-serious” finding does not, however, close your claim for damages, as the remainder of the claimed heads of damages, such as past and future loss of earnings and medical expenses, are assessed separately, subject to the Act’s other limits.

 

How seriousness is assessed

A claimant is assessed by a medical practitioner and the medical practitioner must record the assessment findings in a Serious Injury Assessment Report, as well as a prescribed RAF 4 form.

The RAF 4 form may be submitted after the claim is lodged, and the RAF is liable for general damages only if it is satisfied that the injury was correctly assessed as serious by the medical practitioner.

A claimant’s injuries are serious where these injuries meet certain criteria:

First, an injury is serious if it results in 30% (Thirty percent) or more whole person impairment under the American Medical Association’s Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (6th edition); or[1]

Second, an injury below 30% WPI may still be serious under the “narrative test” if it results in:[2]

  • serious long-term impairment or loss of a body function;
  • permanent serious disfigurement;
  • severe long-term mental or severe long-term behavioural disturbance or disorder; or
  • loss of a foetus.

Under Regulation 3(3), the RAF must decide whether the claimant’s injuries are serious within 90 days of receiving the RAF 4 form. It must do one of three things:

  • accept that the injury was correctly assessed as serious;
  • reject the RAF 4 and give reasons; or
  • direct, at its own cost, that the claimant undergo a further assessment by a medical practitioner of its choice. The RAF must then either accept or dispute that further assessment.

If the RAF does not respond, silence is not deemed to be acceptable. Instead, an attorney is able to bring an application compel the RAF to make a decision in terms of the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000 (PAJA).

 

Disputing the rejection: the RAF 5 and referral to HPCSA

If a claimant disagrees with the RAF’s rejection of the seriousness of his or her injuries, a claimant is able to refer the rejection to the Health Professions Council of South Africa (the HPCSA) that the rejection is disputed. Regulation 3(4) requires this to be done on the prescribed dispute form (the RAF 5 form) within 90 days of being informed of the rejection.

The RAF 5 form must set out the grounds of the dispute, supported by medical reports and opinions. In practice, it should answer each reason the RAF gave for its rejection, with reports from the specialists whose fields match the injuries.

Under Regulation 3(5), if the dispute is not lodged in time, the rejection or assessment becomes final and binding unless an application for condonation is lodged with the Registrar. Condonation is not automatic.

Once the dispute is properly lodged, the Registrar appoints an appeal tribunal of three independent medical practitioners with expertise in the appropriate fields of medicine, who assesses the dispute and the supporting medical documents and reports.[3] The tribunal may, among other things, direct further assessments, examine the claimant, and confirm or substitute the earlier assessment.[4]

The tribunal’s role is narrow. It decides whether the injury is serious or not serious. The tribunal must notify the Registrar of its findings within 90 days of the referral, or within any further period the Registrar authorises in writing.[5]The findings are final and binding,[6] and the RAF bears the reasonable costs of the HPCSA and of the persons appointed to the tribunal.[7]

 

Challenging the tribunals’ findings

“Final and binding” does not mean unchallengeable. The Supreme Court of Appeal in Gouws [8]confirmed that the tribunal’s decision is administrative action, so it can be taken on review in the High Court under PAJA. A review is not a rehearing of the medical evidence. The court asks whether the decision was lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair, and where it finds fault it commonly sets the decision aside and sends the matter back to a newly constituted tribunal rather than deciding seriousness itself.

Two decisions illustrate the grounds. In Coughlan,[9] the Supreme Court of Appeal set aside a finding where the tribunal had strayed into causation and sent the matter back to a properly constituted tribunal. In Qutyana,[10] the High Court set aside a finding where the tribunal rejected a clinical psychologist’s report without engaging with its content.

The time limits are strict – section 7(1) of Promotion of Administrative Justice Act (PAJA) requires a review to be brought without unreasonable delay and no later than 180 days from the tribunal’s finding.

 

Conclusion

A RAF 4 rejection, or failure to decide, is rarely the end of the road. The regulatory framework gives claimants a structured, time bound route to challenge the RAF’s position, and the courts remain available to compel a decision or to review an unlawful or unreasonable finding.

If you or a loved one has been injured in a road accident, get in touch with our team for guidance on your Road Accident Fund claim.

Disclaimer: This article is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

[1] Regulation 3(1)(b)(ii) of the RAF Regulations, 2008

[2] Regulation 3(1)(b)(iii) of the RAF Regulations, 2008

[3] Regulation 3(8) of the RAF Regulations, 2008

[4] Regulation 3(11) of the RAF Regulations, 2008

[5] Regulation 3(12) of the RAF Regulations, 2008

[6] Regulation 3(13) of the RAF Regulations, 2008

[7] Regulation 3(14) of the RAF Regulations, 2008

[8] Road Accident Appeal Tribunal v Gouws 2018 (3) SA 413 (SCA)

[9] Coughlan NO v Health Professions Council of South Africa [2024] ZASCA 135

[10] Qutyana v Health Professions Council of South Africa [2023] ZAGPPHC 629